Interview questions template: How to run structured interviews that work

Why interview templates matter more than ever

Interviewing has always been one of the most time-intensive parts of hiring. Recruiters and hiring managers already spend an estimated 20–30 hours per week on manual, labor-intensive hiring tasks – and without structure, much of that time can easily go to waste. When every interviewer takes a different approach or asks unplanned questions, interviews become inefficient, inconsistent and prone to bias.

Melissa Lobel, Senior Talent Planning Operations Manager at Greenhouse, explains, “interview templates make it possible to standardize flows, save time building interviews from scratch and ensure candidates are evaluated consistently, regardless of interviewer, role or location.”

That consistency has always mattered, but now it’s critical. 

A lack of structure makes hiring even messier, given how AI is transforming the hiring landscape. According to new Greenhouse research, 65% of hiring managers have caught applicants using AI deceptively, and 32% of them have caught candidates reading from AI-generated scripts in interviews. This can lead to polished, uniform responses that can be difficult to evaluate fairly and consistently. Without intentional interview questions designed to test real skills, interviewers risk reacting to confident delivery instead of real evidence – slowing decisions and increasing the risk of expensive hiring mismatches. 

That’s why interview questions templates matter more than ever.

By tying interview questions directly to scorecard attributes, templates help teams reduce friction and make confident, evidence-based hiring decisions, even in today’s complex hiring landscape.
‍

How do interview questions templates work?

An interview questions template is a structured guide that helps interviewers know what to ask, what to listen for and how to evaluate responses consistently. These templates often sit within a broader “template job” – an overarching framework that defines interview stages, evaluation criteria and scorecards across similar roles or levels.

As Melissa explains, “Interview templates are meant to be a starting point. Recruiters can then partner with hiring managers to tailor interviews based on what they actually need to learn from candidates.”

In practice, an interview questions template outlines:

• The flow of interview stages
• The skills or competencies each interview assesses
• The questions used to evaluate those competencies
• The scorecard attributes interviewers use to capture evidence and feedback
• Ownership across the interview panel

Because each question is tied to a scorecard attribute, like communication, collaboration or leadership, interviewers focus on meaningful examples rather than surface-level impressions. This structure reduces redundancy, keeps panels aligned and ensures every interview adds distinct insight.

Interview questions templates can live in shared documents, spreadsheets or ATS interview kits. What matters most is that they support a repeatable, scalable approach to fair and consistent hiring.‍
‍

What’s the difference between an interview questions template and a list of questions?

A list of questions is simply a collection of prompts. An interview questions template turns those prompts into a repeatable system that informs effective hiring decisions.

Templates ensure each question links to a specific competency and define how interviewers should document evidence in a scorecard. This transforms interviews from ad hoc conversations into a structured, data-driven process.

Melissa notes that when every interviewer works from the same template, feedback becomes easier to compare, decisions become clearer and candidates are evaluated on what truly matters – not just who sounds the most confident.

Why templatizing interview questions works

Interview questions templates work because they support structured hiring – an approach designed to improve fairness, consistency and decision quality. Key benefits include:

Ensuring fairness and consistency: Every candidate is asked the same core set of questions tied to clearly defined competencies, reducing the chance for bias or subjective interpretation.

Improving the candidate experience: Candidates notice when an interview feels organized and intentional. Templates give interviewers a shared plan, creating conversations that feel thoughtful while also displaying professionalism and respect for the candidate’s time.

Reducing manual prep: Instead of reinventing questions for every role or interviewer, templates provide a reliable starting point. They can be quickly customized for different positions or levels, cutting down on prep time while maintaining quality.

Supporting data-driven decisions: With standardized prompts and scorecards, interviewers can easily document evidence and compare candidates on the same criteria. This structured data helps hiring teams move beyond gut feeling and toward measurable, evidence-based decisions.

Keeping interview panels aligned: Templates clarify each interviewer’s focus area, whether that’s technical ability, collaboration, leadership or values alignment. With defined responsibilities, every conversation adds a unique perspective, minimizing redundancy and ensuring all key competencies are covered.

The downsides of not using interview templates

When interview questions templates aren’t in place, interview quality can vary widely from one conversation to the next. This leads to several common issues:

Inconsistent candidate experiences: When each interviewer asks different questions that unevenly assess criteria, candidates can walk away with mixed impressions of your organization. This inconsistency can make your process feel disorganized and weaken trust in your brand.

Higher risk of bias: Unstructured interviews leave room for subjective or off-topic questions that can introduce bias, even unintentionally. Without a standardized framework, it’s harder to ensure fairness or hold teams accountable for equitable hiring practices.

Longer time-to-hire: Without shared templates, interviewers often spend extra time preparing, aligning and reviewing feedback. This duplicated effort slows down hiring cycles and creates more administrative work for recruiters.

Redundant interviews: A lack of clear focus areas across the interview panel can cause conversations to overlap. Candidates end up repeating the same anecdotes or examples across multiple stages, creating frustration for both sides and missing opportunities to explore new insights.

Poor decision data: Unstructured notes that vary in format or detail make it difficult to compare candidates objectively. When final decisions rely on scattered impressions instead of consistent data, the risk of a hiring mismatch increases.

Types of interview question templates (by role, stage or competency)

While templates provide a shared starting point, they aren’t strictly one-size-fits-all. Interview question templates should adapt based on the type of role, interview stage and skills being assessed.

Role-based templates focus on the competencies unique to a position, such as technical knowledge for engineers or storytelling ability for writers. They tie each question directly to the realities of the role, helping teams identify candidates with the most relevant experience.

Stage-based templates align questions to each step of the hiring process. Early-stage interviews emphasize general qualifications and communication skills, while later stages dig deeper into functional expertise or leadership behaviors. Together, they create a complete view of each candidate’s fit.

Competency-based templates group questions by skill areas such as collaboration, problem-solving, adaptability and leadership. Each conversation evaluates a measurable capability so candidates are compared on the same dimensions.

These templates can flex depending on company size, team structure and process maturity. Recruiting coordinators might use them to guide early screenings, while hiring managers apply them to assess technical depth or team fit. 

The key is scalability. Templates should be easy to customize, repeat and share across your organization. Smaller organizations often rely on shared documents or spreadsheets, while larger teams use ATS-integrated versions that automate workflows and centralize feedback.

How interview templates fit into a structured hiring process

Structured hiring is an approach built around:

• Defining what success looks like for each role
• Assessing candidates using shared standards
• Making decisions based on evidence, not instinct

Interview templates are the operational layer that makes structured hiring possible.

By assigning each interviewer a specific focus area and tying questions directly to scorecard attributes, templates ensure interviews build on one another. Instead of fragmented observations, hiring teams gain a well-rounded view of each candidate’s strengths and potential.

Ultimately, structured hiring creates a process that’s fairer for candidates, more consistent for interviewers and more effective at identifying the right person for the job. When every interviewer is aligned and every conversation is purposeful, teams hire candidates who not only meet the requirements but are able to thrive in the role.

How to use templates the right way

Interview templates work best when they provide structure without feeling too rigid. When applied thoughtfully, they help interviewers show up prepared and focused, cultivating conversations that are both insightful and authentic.

“Treat interview templates as a starting point, not a script. Use them to create a fair, consistent interview flow, then work with hiring managers to tailor questions to what you really need to learn for a specific role.”
– Melissa Lobel, Senior Talent Planning Operations Manager at Greenhouse

Tailor by role and level: A single template can’t capture the nuances of every position. Adjust core questions to reflect the specific skills, scope and expectations of each role so evaluations stay relevant and meaningful.

Mix consistent and custom questions: Keep a core set of questions steady across interviews to maintain fairness, but layer in role-specific variations to gain a deeper understanding of each candidate’s experience.

Differentiate by interview stage: Each conversation should build on the last. Assign distinct focus areas – like values, collaboration or technical skill – so interviews complement each other rather than overlap.

Include follow-up guidance: Add short notes or sample probes beneath each question to help interviewers dig deeper and capture stronger examples. This ensures consistency in depth, not just in structure.

Use templates as guides, not scripts: Structure is meant to keep interviews on track, not strip away genuine connection. The best interviews blend preparation with curiosity and leave room for natural dialogue.

‍

Sample role-based interview questions template

Example role: Software engineer

Technical skill assessment
Purpose: Measure analytical thinking and approach to solving technical issues.
Example: “How do you approach resolving performance issues in production code?”

Collaboration assessment
Purpose: Understand communication and teamwork in cross-functional or engineering environments.
Example: “Tell me about a time you disagreed with a teammate or reviewer on a technical approach. How did you resolve it?”

Coachability
Purpose: Assess openness to feedback and willingness to learn from experience.
Example: “Describe a time you received constructive feedback on your code – what did you learn, and how did you apply it in future work?”

Sample stage-based interview questions template

Phone screen

Performed by: Recruiter or coordinator
Purpose: Validate interest and high-level fit.
Examples:

• “Can you give me a quick overview of your background?”
• “What drew you to this role?”

Functional or collaboration interview
Performed by: Hiring manager or peer

Purpose: Assess skills, behaviors and team fit.
Examples: 

• “Tell me about a recent project you led or contributed to.”
• “How do you prioritize your work when managing multiple requests from stakeholders?”

Leadership or executive round
Performed by: Senior leaders, executives or founders

Purpose: Evaluate strategic thinking, values alignment and long-term impact.
Examples: 

• “How do you make decisions when there’s no clear answer?”
• “Describe a time you had to lead through change.”

Sample competency-based interview questions template

‍Problem-solving

Purpose: Understand how candidates approach challenges and decision-making under uncertainty.
Example: “Tell me about a time you had to solve a difficult problem with limited information.”
‍

Adaptability

Purpose: Evaluate how candidates respond to change and adjust strategies midstream.
Example: “Describe a situation where you had to adjust your approach midway through a project.”
‍

Teamwork

Purpose: Gauge collaboration skills and conflict resolution in team settings.
Example: “What’s the toughest group you’ve worked with, and how did you handle it?
‍

Building better interviews through structure

Great interviews don’t happen by chance. Behind every strong hiring decision is a thoughtful structure that helps teams focus on the right questions, assess candidates fairly and make confident decisions, even in today’s challenging hiring landscape.

Interview questions templates give hiring teams a repeatable, equitable way to evaluate candidates, saving time and reducing hiring bias while helping every conversation feel more intentional and productive.

Rather than add formality, structured interviewing is about creating alignment for recruiters, hiring managers and candidates alike. When every question is purposeful and aligned, the entire interview process becomes more focused, more efficient and more human.

Ready to make an offer after using an interview questions template to identify the right candidate? Use this free job offer letter template to move fast and close strong.